Blair Witch: not biting the Bullet

You get to adopt a pet from any fictional word you want; why did you pick it? This is one of the questions Carla from Pop Culture Literary posed to her Sunshine Blogger Award nominees last month. And I think I’ve found an animal who’s in dire need of adoption.

You see, a few weeks ago my other-half and I started playing Blair Witch. It was one of the only titles revealed during Microsoft’s E3 presentation back in June that we were actually interested in so when we had a free weekend recently, we jumped onto his Xbox Game Pass subscription and downloaded it. Neither of us had read any articles or reviews so we didn’t know what we were letting ourselves in for – although we expected to be terrified if the original film was anything to go by.

If you haven’t yet played this game and intend to do so, I’d recommend navigating away from this post now and coming back later. There are some minor spoilers in the following paragraphs.

The Blair Witch Project came out in 1999. It may be 20 years old but that long period hasn’t made me forget just how scared I was when I went to see it with a friend at a local cinema during the week of its release. The filmmakers’ attempts to promote the film with realistic ‘missing persons’ posters and unique ‘found footage’ plot device had a huge impact on the audience; I can remember cowering in my seat while everyone around me screamed, before walking home and casting frequent looks back over my shoulder.

So why on earth was I excited about the video game? Regular visitors will know just how much of a wimp I am when it comes to the horror genre and that I make Pete take the controller during such titles so I can watch the screen from behind the safety of a cushion. The strange thing is though that I really enjoy a horror storyline. I grew up reading books by Stephen King and Dean Koontz from an early age after my dad gave me a copy of The Dark Tower, and so the thought of a Blair Witch game had me intrigued.

It takes place in 1996, two years after the events in The Blair Witch Project, when Ellis travels back to the Black Hills Forest with his dog Bullet to join a search party looking for nine-year old Peter Shannon. What starts out as an ordinary investigation soon turns into a nightmare when it becomes clear a mysterious force is lurking among the trees. Armed with only a cell phone, flashlight, backpack and canine companion, will Ellis make it through the night or succumb to his decaying sanity?

So far we’re around two hours in and… it’s not all that scary. Well, at least not for the reasons you’d usually associate with an entry in the horror genre and there’ll be more about that very soon. At first, finding your way through the forest as the darkness descends with only Bullet’s growls and whimpers to alert you to danger is creepy; but once the affect wears off it feels a bit repetitive. Especially when you encounter blockers and keep having to make your way back to the same central point.

The found footage is there in a mechanic which ties the game nicely to the film, and it does have some use in terms of gameplay. You’ll find abandoned camcorders within the woods and watching these will reveal a clue as to what’s happened to Peter. Stop the footage at the right time and you’ll find something had changed in the current environment; for example, an early video shows the kid playing with a toy police car near a campfire and you’re able to make this appear in front of you.

But it feels like it’s ripped-off from Resident Evil 7: Biohazard. This release used flashbacks to flesh out its story (zombie pun not intended) in the form of VHS tapes, in a way where it was possible to interact with the environment shown in them that would have an impact on the protagonist’s own adventure. Blair Witch’s enemies don’t feel all that unique either; we’ve had the shine-a-torch-at-them-to-drive-them-away mechanic before in older titles such as Alan Wake.

Sadly, these aren’t the only grievances I have with the game so far. Perhaps my biggest issue is with Ellis’s background: how many times have you played a horror where the main character is a ‘former policeman with a troubled past’? Shortly after loading it up I made a comment to my other-half that my guess was he was a veteran suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) – and it wasn’t long before we experienced his first memory. We’re may be only a couple of hours in but it already feels so cliched.

Perhaps things will change the further we progress and the protagonist’s backstory may tie in with what’s going on in Black Hills Forest without it becoming a tired trope. But unfortunately, I’m not sure we’re ever going to find out. Remember I said above that this game wasn’t scary for the usual reasons? Forget scuttling sounds heard behind you, monsters lurking in dark corners and jump-scares that make you yelp; there’s something in Blair Witch that frightens me far more than any of these.

Blair Witch, video game, dog, Alsation, German Shepherd, Bullet


I absolutely hate it when animals are hurt during video games. I’m not sure what this says about me or how much I’ve become desensitised throughout my gaming life, but it affects me far more than when a person gets wounded onscreen and I just can’t bear to watch. Agro the horse from Shadow of the Colossus, the dog from Fable II, Trico the cat-dog-thing from The Last Guardian – all good companions who didn’t deserve to have a hair on their head harmed.

We all know the outcome for canine characters in any horror media. Your faithful friend remains loyal, tries to protect you from supernatural baddies, alerts you to their presence in the shadows with growls before going for their throats. And what happens? They always end up giving their life to save yours. I’m sure developers, filmmakers and authors make sure they include a dog in their projects simply to punch us in the gut when they meet a grisly death.

That’s why I’m not sure I’m going to be able to bring myself to finish Blair Witch. I can’t stand the thought of anything bad happening to Bullet because he has been such a good boy so far, and it’s bad enough listening to him whimper when he’s frightened. Pete is kind of glad I feel this way though and don’t want to jump straight back into the game; he’s not sure how many more times he can face finding another blocker and having to loop back around to the same point in the woods.

There’s only one thing for it: Bullet needs to be adopted, brought into a good home and given a few treats. Thanks once again to Carla for the Sunshine Blogger Award nomination – I’m sure she’ll come with me to Black Hills Forest to rescue that dog.

10 thoughts on “Blair Witch: not biting the Bullet

  1. I’m absolutely gutted I couldn’t finish this game (due to my xbox dieing on me recently), despite being a massive horror cliche, I actually thought it could have gotten better as I progressed. I loved the idea of how Bullet keeps you company and you can get lonely, furthering the effects of the character’s PTSD. It just adds an extra layer for your companion, other than just being a cute furry friend you dont want anything to happen to. Will definitely have to keep on eye out for your walkthrough videos though.


    • I’m just not sure I’m going to be able to finish it… if anything bad happened to Bullet, I know I’d be heartbroken! I still think that the protagonist’s background is a huge cliché (at least from what I’ve seen of the game so far). But I did like the way you had to balance sending the dog out to scout ahead, and keeping him by your side to prevent the loneliness from setting in.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Animals to adopt from video games 🤔 Good question. If it were any fictional work, then it would be a bird, like the phoenix in Harry Potter, but in video games, maybe the youki from Syberia. Though my first thought went to the *ahem*”sleeping” dogs in The Secret of Monkey Island. I mean, we never saw them again. What happened to them?

    I haven’t played Blair Witch though, it’s one of those where I think I would have to watch the movie first, but I don’t want to watch the movie.


    • The Youki… now that’s a good choice. 😍

      I’m a big coward when it comes to horror films and games, so I wouldn’t recommend watching the movie! I know the whole ‘found footage’ thing is old-hat now but at the time it was released in the cinemas, it was something we’d never seen before. I just remember the whole audience screaming at certain points.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. I hate when something happens to animals in games too. In Assassin’s Creed Syndicate there’s a bit where you are having to shoot people whilst you are on one of the horse drawn carriages and so are there. My issue was my aim whilst moving with that weapon was rubbish and I kept getting upset when I hit the horses. Actually any point when I was trying to stop other carriages chasing me if I thought I hurt the horse I was annoyed with myself and upset and that happened a few times in other sections but the bit where you had to shoot was the worst for me.


    • I have a phobia of horses (more about that next week)… but I don’t want to see them get hurt, not even in games! There’s just something about seeing animals get injured that makes me feel a whole lot worse than when it happens to the characters. 😦


      • I definitely feel worse with animals but it’s the same in films. I’m not as worried about the humans but the second it looks like an animal is going to be hurt I’m in tears. I just want all the animals to be safe and happy and it doesn’t always happen that way.


        • I went to the cinema years ago to see a horror film… I can’t remember what is was now… but there was a scene involving a dog and a microwave that I’ll never forget. I left the building in tears!


  4. I had higher expectations, to be honest. After the first 30 minutes or so, the story felt like it was missing. . . A certain something. I couldn’t bring myself to play an hour of it, much less finish the entire game.


    • We haven’t gone back to the game since writing this post and… to be honest, I’m not sure we will. There just doesn’t seem to be much there to keep you going and I don’t particularly like the PTSD backstory. Maybe it’s because I saw the original film at the time of release and nostalgia is making me remember just how scary it was; but yeah, I totally agree that something seems to be missing.

      Liked by 1 person

Join the discussion

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.