Call of the Sea: puzzles in paradise

Call of the Sea has been on my wishlist since I first saw its trailer a few months ago. It stood out back then due to its lovely visuals and mysterious premise – and it stands out now because it’s a recent addition to the Xbox Game Pass which isn’t another shooter.

Having the subscription during the past year of lockdown has been beneficial as it’s given me the chance to fill those extra free hours by trying titles in genres I wouldn’t normally be interested in. Take Yakuza 0 for example; I was able to give it a go without the risk of buying a game I might not enjoy and ended up finding something that’s a lot of fun. My only complaint about Microsoft’s line-up is that tends to be action-heavy and as a result, I’ve already played most of the narrative-based releases available.

That’s why I jumped on Call of the Sea by Out of the Blue shortly after its release at the beginning of December. Set in the 1930s, it tells the tale of a woman named Norah Everhart who suffers from a strange illness which causes black blotches to appear on her arms. She embarks on a journey to a small island 74-miles east of Tahiti after her husband Harry disappeared there while searching for a cure. What is she going to find waiting for her and where has her spouse gone?

The articles I’ve read about the game since completing it have tended to liken it to Myst and The Witness. I have to say that neither of these sprang to mind during my playthrough and I don’t entirely agree with these comparisons, outside of the appearance of challenges on an island. To me, it felt more like a series of escape rooms: finding the clues to solve each puzzle within a chapter opened the doorway to the next and allowed Norah to progress on her quest.

The clues mentioned there come in various formats but you can usually glean a lot of information from the items left behind by Harry’s team and the notes scattered around each location. You always seem to be just one step behind your husband so you must use his drawings, letters and photographs to figure out how he made it past the current obstacle. If you get stuck, you can always look at Norah’s journal for a recap of the story so far along with the most important details.

Although Call of the Sea isn’t the most challenging or the longest adventure I’ve ever experienced, it did feature a nice difficulty curve and didn’t outstay its welcome. There was one particular puzzle which had us stumped for a good 30-minutes around two-thirds of the way in (I’m putting this down to tiredness due to the late time) but at no point during our eight-hours did we feel the need to turn to a walkthrough. The pace felt mostly constant, a good thing as you don’t want your momentum to be slowed down in narrative titles like this.

There were only two minor negatives I picked up on in terms of gameplay. First was that I didn’t enjoy the later swimming sections as much as some of the other parts of the game because they felt a little slower; and second was that Norah really isn’t a fast walker. This does make some narrative sense as she explains her illness causes weakness but even holding the ‘run’ button doesn’t speed her up very much. Still, at least you have plenty of stunning scenery to look at while you’re strolling along.

I couldn’t help but take a couple of screenshots while playing and post them on Twitter. They’re exactly what you’d expect of a tropical island – white sands, blue waves and glowing sunsets – and several friends in Twitch chat remarked how much the graphics looked like Firewatch. The settings in the later chapters change to a stormy beach complete with shipwreck, a mountain-top with murals and an ancient temple, each of them beautiful in a distinct way.

Norah’s inner monologues through her journey reveal details about her relationship with Harry and it’s lovely to see that these protagonists consider themselves as equals. Forget the 1930s view about a woman’s place being in the home; the way these two refer to each other as ‘my dear old pal’, a reference to their favourite song, shows they’re best friends as well as partners. It does go some way towards making your final decision more poignant but sadly it’s not as poignant as it could have been.

The start of Call of the Sea feels as though the island is crammed full of mysteries, and certain items uncovered hint at something dark and horrible happening to Harry and his expedition. This feeling continues throughout the title but observant players will be able to figure out what’s going on well before the conclusion is reached. At certain points we found ourselves talking to the screen and asking Norah why she still didn’t have a clue, because it just seemed so obvious to everyone watching.

This did the protagonist, who initially seemed like a very intelligent and determined woman, a disservice by making her come across as somewhat oblivious. Her habit of expressing shock at something alarming revealed in Harry’s notes and then immediately making a humorous comment about the next item observed made her seem distracted. Not that you wouldn’t be distracted if you had a weird illness and your husband had disappeared on a remote island several months ago, but you get what I mean.

Still, the final choice players find themselves confronted with in chapter six is a fitting one. The fact it’s a binary decision was frowned upon by one person who joined us for our stream but to me, it felt as though it suited the characters and their situation. There’s no good or bad ending regardless of which option you pick because Call of the Sea is a game which explores what it means to love someone and being true to yourself, and as such there are no perfect answers.

This is the first release from Out of the Blue and it’s a very promising start. Despite the shortcomings of the narrative and the minor niggles I had with the gameplay, I’d recommend Call of the Sea to adventure fans or anyone who’s looking to get lost in a story set in a beautiful location. If the team can take what they’ve learnt from making this game and use the experience in their next project, I can’t wait to see what they come up with next.

We’re taking part in GameBlast21 to support SpecialEffect, the gamers’ charity.
Making a donation will bring you great loot, increase your XP by +100 and make you immune to fire.*
(*Not guaranteed.)

12 thoughts on “Call of the Sea: puzzles in paradise

  1. This is why I love watching you on Twitch. I’d never have the patience play this game for myself, but seeing it in action while discussing the story as it unfolded was a great experience. Puns also make everything better! 😁


    • Aw that’s nice to hear! We were always under the impression that these more puzzle-orientated games were boring to watch because they can be quite slow, but we enjoy them – so it’s nice to know that somebody else does too. 😉

      Liked by 1 person

      • I hear so many cool streamer friends, including you and Petez0rz, often say the games they choose aren’t “entertaining enough” for their audience. I’m sorry, but you’re all WRONG! Ha ha.

        The game is honestly irrelevant, in my opinion. What’s important is that the streamer has fun presenting the game they are playing to their audience. You can easily tell if a streamer is doing something against what they truly think is fun just to be “popular”, if that makes sense.

        You and Pete rock the puzzle-oriented games and that is incredibly fun to watch. You help each other and your passion for the genre definitely shines through on stream.

        Also, I caught the VOD for the Master System stream and was honestly sad when Pete stopped playing retro games because he thought the audience was bored with watching him “fail”. Not true at all! (It was cool watching you play Yakuza 0 again though)

        There is actually a thriving retro gaming community on Twitch. These streamers get the butts of their controllers handed to them all the time by crushing classic games, yet they have huge audiences who turn out to support them. You know why? It’s because those streamers love the games they are playing and that positivity is infectious.

        TL;DR – Stop thinking you’re boring. You and Petez0rz are legit highly entertaining people. Play what you really wanna play for an audience!


        • Wow, go genniz0rz! ❤

          The Master System stream was a weird night. The emergency call from work took longer than I expected and Pete always feels uncomfortable streaming on his own for more than five minutes. Still, I think it has given him a taste for more retro games – he wants to track down a copy of Wonder Boy in Monster Land, and there are a couple of games I want for my PS2 so there might be another retro night soon.

          We'll still keep playing adventure and puzzle games regardless of how slow some people might think they are (there are a couple of posts kind of related to this coming up). They're the kind of games I enjoy and, as you pointed out, the most important thing is having fun on stream. And if our friends want to hang out with us while we do it, then that's even better. 😉

          Liked by 1 person

          • Yes!! Looking forward to seeing anything you want to show off on stream. Also interested to see what these upcoming posts are about.

            Fair warning though. I will tell you guys off next time you imply you’re “not entertaining”. You are both awesome streamers who play cool games! /End Rant ♥


  2. I watched the trailer and I’m on board with this. I don’t think I have access to Xbox Series XIS as I’m assuming it’s for Xbone exclusively? It looks like PC is an option, though so I’m definitely looking into this.


  3. I’ve just finished Call of the Sea and fall into the category of those who found parts reminiscent of the Witness. I think it was partly the setting and art-style and partly the observational skills needed to solve some of the puzzles.

    Are there any other similar narrative/puzzle games you’d recommend on gamepass? I’ve already played and enjoyed Oxenfree, What Remains of Edith Finch, and Carto.


    • You’re going to start me off on a ramble now: adventure games are one of my favourite things to talk about! Let’s see…

      – A Way Out is good if there’s someone you can play with
      – Sea of Solitude is a really beautiful puzzle-platformer that has a lovely story
      – The Gardens Between is an excellent game that can be completed in one sitting
      – Full Throttle, Grim Fandango and Machinarium are good point-and-clicks
      – Kathy Rain has a great ‘Twin Peaks’ kind of vibe
      – Eastshade ended up being one of my favourite games

      Hope that helps! 😀

      Liked by 1 person

Join the discussion

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.